Does Bread From Bread Machines Taste The Same As Handmade Bread

We love the taste and smell of freshly baked bread in our household, and we often debate whether bread made from a bread machine tastes the same as handmade bread. As a family who enjoys baking, we have experimented with both methods and have come to some conclusions. In this article, we will explore the basics of bread making, including texture, appearance, and flavor, as well as the convenience, time, and cost factors of bread machines versus handmade bread.

When it comes to bread making, there is something special about kneading the dough by hand and watching it rise. However, we understand that not everyone has the time, energy, or desire to make bread from scratch. Bread machines have become increasingly popular in recent years, and many people swear by them for their convenience and ease of use. But does the bread taste the same? That’s what we set out to discover, and we hope our findings will help you decide which method is best for you.

The Basics of Bread Making

You’ll find a wealth of information on the fundamental principles of baking your own delicious loaves in this section. Bread making is a simple yet complex process that requires a basic understanding of the ingredients, techniques, and tools. The main ingredients in bread making are flour, water, yeast, and salt. Flour provides the structure and texture of the bread, water hydrates the dough, yeast leavens the bread, and salt enhances the flavor and controls the fermentation process.

To make bread, you need to mix the ingredients together, knead the dough, let it rise, shape it, and bake it. The mixing process involves combining the dry and wet ingredients until a dough forms. Kneading the dough involves working it with your hands or a machine to develop the gluten, which is the protein that gives bread its elasticity and strength. Letting the dough rise gives the yeast time to ferment the sugars in the dough, which produces carbon dioxide gas that causes the dough to expand. Shaping the dough involves forming it into a desired shape, such as a loaf or roll. Finally, baking the bread involves placing it in an oven and cooking it until it’s golden brown and fully cooked.

Bread making requires patience, practice, and attention to detail. It’s important to measure the ingredients accurately, use the right temperature and humidity for rising the dough, and bake the bread until it’s fully cooked. While bread machines can make the process easier and more convenient, they may not produce the same results as handmade bread. The machine may not knead the dough as well as you could by hand, and the bread may have a different texture and flavor. Nonetheless, bread machines can be a great tool for beginners or busy bakers who don’t have the time or energy to make bread by hand.

Texture and Appearance

When we make bread, one of the things we often consider is its texture and appearance. The crust texture can range from soft and tender to crusty and crunchy, depending on the type of bread and how it was baked. The crumb texture, or the inside of the bread, can vary from dense and chewy to light and airy. Additionally, the appearance of the loaf can be influenced by factors such as shaping and scoring.

Crust Texture

The crust of bread made in a machine has a texture that can’t compare to the artisanal touch of a skilled baker. While bread machines can produce a crust that is crispy and golden brown, it often lacks the complexity and variation that comes with handmade bread. The crust made by a machine is typically uniform in thickness and lacks the natural irregularities that are characteristic of handmade bread.

Additionally, bread machines tend to produce a crust that is softer and more tender than that of handmade bread. This is because bread machines often use steam during the baking process to create a moist environment that prevents the crust from becoming too hard. While this can be desirable for certain types of bread, it can also result in a less satisfying texture overall. Ultimately, while bread made in a machine can be convenient and consistent, it lacks the unique qualities that come with the human touch of a skilled baker.

Crumb Texture

Get ready for a mouthwatering experience as we dive into the texture of the crumb in your freshly baked loaf. One of the most important factors in determining the quality of bread is its crumb texture. The crumb refers to the inner part of the bread that is soft and airy. When comparing bread from bread machines to handmade bread, the crumb texture can differ greatly.

Bread machines are designed to mix and knead the dough, and then bake it all in one convenient appliance. This process can result in a denser and less airy crumb. On the other hand, handmade bread requires more time and care in the kneading and rising process. It often results in a lighter and more delicate crumb texture. However, this can also vary depending on the recipe and technique used. Ultimately, the crumb texture of bread from a bread machine versus handmade bread can vary greatly and it’s up to personal preference which one is preferred.

Appearance of the Loaf

Take a look at the loaf’s appearance and you’ll see how its outer layer gives a glimpse of what’s inside. Bread from bread machines often have a uniform shape and a smooth, slightly glossy crust. The crust is achieved through the steam that the machine releases during the baking process. The crust may not be as thick or crispy as handmade bread, but it is still a satisfying texture. The crust of bread machine-made bread is usually a bit thinner than that of handmade bread. This is because bread machines do not allow the dough to rise as much as handmade bread would. However, the crust is still an important factor in the overall appearance of the loaf.

When it comes to the crumb of the bread, bread machine-made bread usually has a slightly smaller and more consistent crumb. The crumb of handmade bread, on the other hand, can vary greatly depending on the baker’s technique. Bread machine-made bread often has a more even distribution of air pockets, which can make it seem less rustic than handmade bread. Overall, the appearance of bread machine-made bread may not be as artisanal as handmade bread, but it is still an attractive and satisfying loaf.


You’ll notice a distinct difference in the flavor of bread made in a bread machine versus bread made by hand. While bread machines are convenient and produce a consistent loaf, they often lack the depth of flavor that handmade bread has. This is because bread machines typically use the same basic ingredients for every loaf, whereas handmade bread allows for more variation in ingredients and technique.

When making bread by hand, you have more control over the ingredients and can adjust them to create a unique flavor profile. For example, you can use different types of flour, add herbs or spices, or incorporate sourdough starter. This results in a bread with a more complex and nuanced flavor. In contrast, bread machines often produce a bland, uniform flavor that lacks character and depth.

Overall, while bread machines offer convenience and consistency, they cannot replicate the depth of flavor that handmade bread provides. If you are looking for a truly delicious and unique loaf, it is worth taking the time to make it by hand. The extra effort will be well worth it when you take that first bite and savor the rich, complex flavor that only handmade bread can provide.

Convenience and Time

If you’re short on time but still want fresh, homemade bread, using a bread machine can be a convenient option. Bread machines are designed to take the guesswork out of bread making. You simply add the ingredients, select the settings, and let the machine do the rest. This can save you a lot of time and effort, especially if you’re new to bread making or don’t have a lot of experience in the kitchen.

Bread machines also have the advantage of being able to make bread at any time of day or night. This means you can wake up to the smell of freshly baked bread, or have a warm loaf waiting for you when you come home from work. This convenience can be a real lifesaver, especially if you have a busy schedule or don’t have a lot of time to spend in the kitchen. Plus, bread machines can be programmed to make a variety of different types of bread, so you can experiment with different recipes and flavors.

Of course, there are some downsides to using a bread machine. For one thing, the bread may not have the same texture or flavor as handmade bread. This is because bread machines tend to produce loaves that are more uniform in shape and texture, which can sometimes make them feel a bit artificial. Additionally, some people find that bread made in a bread machine is not as crusty or chewy as handmade bread. However, if you’re looking for a quick and easy way to make bread at home, a bread machine can still be a great option.


Let’s talk about the cost of using a bread machine, and how it can affect your budget for homemade baked goods. Bread machines are generally affordable and come in a range of prices, depending on the features and functions they offer. A basic bread machine can cost around $50, while a more advanced one with additional settings and options can cost up to $300. However, the initial cost of the machine is only one aspect to consider when looking at the overall cost of making bread at home.

In addition to the cost of the bread machine itself, there are also the costs of ingredients and energy consumption to consider. Homemade bread requires flour, yeast, salt, sugar, and other ingredients, which can add up over time. However, buying these ingredients in bulk can help reduce the cost per loaf. Energy consumption is also a factor, as bread machines require electricity to operate. While the cost of running a bread machine is relatively low, it should still be factored into the overall cost of making bread at home.

Overall, while there may be some initial costs associated with purchasing a bread machine and buying ingredients, making bread at home can save money in the long run. Not only is homemade bread typically less expensive than store-bought bread, but it also allows for more control over the ingredients used and can be customized to individual tastes and preferences. In addition, the convenience of a bread machine can save time and money by eliminating the need to purchase bread from a bakery or grocery store.

Personal Preference

You might find yourself getting excited about the personalization and uniqueness that comes with making your own baked goods at home. When it comes to bread, there’s a certain satisfaction that comes with working the dough by hand and seeing it rise before your eyes. However, the convenience of a bread machine can’t be ignored. So, the question remains: does bread from a bread machine taste the same as handmade bread?

In my experience, the answer is no. While bread from a bread machine can be tasty and convenient, it doesn’t quite match the flavor and texture of handmade bread. The process of making bread by hand allows for more control over the ingredients and the texture of the dough. Plus, the act of kneading the dough by hand can be therapeutic and satisfying.

That being said, personal preference plays a huge role in this debate. Some may prefer the consistency and convenience of bread from a machine, while others may prioritize the unique flavor and texture of handmade bread. Ultimately, it comes down to what you value in your bread. Whether you choose to make it by hand or with a machine, the process of baking your own bread is still a rewarding and delicious endeavor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are bread machines easy to clean and maintain?

When it comes to cleaning and maintaining bread machines, we’ve found that they’re generally pretty easy to take care of. Most models come with removable bread pans and kneading paddles that can be washed in the sink or dishwasher. Some even have non-stick coatings that make cleanup a breeze. It’s important to wipe down the interior of the machine after each use to prevent buildup of flour and other debris. As for maintenance, regular cleaning and occasional oiling of moving parts should keep your bread machine running smoothly for years. Overall, we’ve found that bread machines are a convenient and low-maintenance way to make homemade bread.

Can you make gluten-free bread in a bread machine?

Yes, you can definitely make gluten-free bread in a bread machine. In fact, many bread machines have a specific setting for gluten-free bread. When making gluten-free bread in a bread machine, it is important to use the right type of flour and to follow the recipe carefully. Gluten-free bread dough is usually stickier than regular bread dough, so it is important to use a spatula to scrape down the sides of the bread pan during the mixing and kneading process. Overall, making gluten-free bread in a bread machine is a convenient and easy way to enjoy fresh, homemade bread without the hassle of kneading and rising the dough by hand.

How much noise do bread machines make while in operation?

When it comes to the noise level of bread machines, it really depends on the model you have. Some bread machines are relatively quiet while others can be quite noisy. Generally, the noise level will largely depend on the motor and how powerful it is. If you have a more powerful motor, you can expect the machine to be a bit louder than one with a weaker motor. However, most bread machines do come with a noise level rating, so you can get an idea of what to expect before purchasing. Overall, if you’re sensitive to noise, it might be a good idea to do some research on the quietest bread machines available.

Can you adjust the crust color and thickness on a bread machine?

Yes, you can adjust the crust color and thickness on a bread machine. Most bread machines come with a crust control feature that allows you to control the level of browning on the crust. The crust control feature typically has three settings: light, medium, and dark. If you prefer a thinner crust, you can also adjust the thickness of the crust by selecting the “thin crust” option on your bread machine. This feature is particularly useful if you prefer a softer crust or if you are making a sandwich bread. Overall, adjusting the crust color and thickness on a bread machine is a simple and convenient way to customize your bread to your liking.

Do bread machines come with a warranty or guarantee?

When it comes to purchasing a bread machine, many consumers may wonder if the appliance comes with a warranty or guarantee. The good news is that most bread machines do come with some form of warranty or guarantee. The length and specifics of the warranty may vary depending on the brand and model of the machine, so it is important to read the fine print before making a purchase. In general, warranties may cover defects in materials or workmanship, while guarantees may offer a satisfaction guarantee or money-back guarantee. It is always a good idea to keep the original packaging and receipt in case any issues arise with the machine.


In conclusion, our exploration of the differences between bread made from bread machines and handmade bread has revealed that there are both similarities and differences. While the basics of bread making remain the same, there are noticeable differences in texture, appearance, and flavor that can be attributed to the use of a bread machine. However, convenience and time are major factors that make bread machines a popular choice among many home bakers.

It is important to note that personal preference plays a significant role in determining which method of bread making is preferred. Some individuals may prefer the convenience and consistency of bread machine bread, while others may appreciate the unique flavor and texture of handmade bread. Ultimately, the choice between using a bread machine or making bread by hand depends on individual preferences, priorities, and needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © 2022 LEMON & LIMES.
Made with by Loft.Ocean. All rights reserved.